29
Jul 08Gaming IMDB – The stupidity of crowds?
A CNET blog post by Harrison Hoffman reported on the efforts by fans to elevate the new Batman film The Dark Night to the number one position on IMDB’s list of the top 250 films of all time. Hoffman uses this and the Digg HD/DVD key incident (discussed by Clay Shirky in Here Comes Everybody) as examples of the failure of the wisdom of crowds.
I can sort-of buy the idea that the IMDB gaming incident represents a failure, though I would argue that it’s only a minor one. Having The Godfather drop to number two or even three on the list seems like evidence for a temporal mobbing weakness in the ranking implementation. More…